Quantcast

Brandy's Brokenhearted, Aaliyah's The One I Gave My Heart To, or Monica's Why I Love You So Much

Brandy's Brokenhearted, Aaliyah's The One I Gave My Heart To, or Monica's Why I Love You So Much?

  • Brokenhearted

    Votes: 121 46.2%
  • The One I Gave My Heart To

    Votes: 45 17.2%
  • Why I Love You So Much

    Votes: 96 36.6%

  • Total voters
    262

TheReal_Ness

Team Owner
Joined
May 14, 2007
Messages
10,487
Reaction score
Reactions
39,535 727 457
43,537
Alleybux
518,602
giphy.gif


It’s enough going on the world. These threads are for us to reminisce on great music. Every single one of these artists have made an impact. This is not stan wars. I repeat: This is not stan wars. And sunkissedbri, Miss Thang (pun intended), that mouth of yours needs a granny tapping! Keep it cute or leave!

I absolutely agree. I was speaking on the false information her goofy ass posted and apparently the girls don't like when facts are posted that challenge their bµllsh!t ass narratives. I enjoy all 3 songs and artists listed.
 

BLVCK

always disgusted
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
8,593
Reaction score
Reactions
157,233 5,834 3,948
185,751
Alleybux
35,588
Oh I posted facts, the sh!t you posted was feelings. And I love how that sh!t was edited after the fact. If you b!tches don’t learn to research before running your ignorance on this here site, that sounds like a personal problem. Hence posting gifs instead of adequate responses. Goofy asses.
I said what I said!!!

I
tumblr_inline_pafhbpLJI71sneeo8_500.gif


source.gif
X8wc.gif
 

BLVCK

always disgusted
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
8,593
Reaction score
Reactions
157,233 5,834 3,948
185,751
Alleybux
35,588
Stfy lyinggg! You can't prove sh!t that you posted. I actually posted #s but if you weren't an overly emotional, butt hurt illiterate bird, you would've seen it :laughing:
WAIT A MINUTEEEEEEEEE

eve.png


Stop talking to one another! You both said what you said now let it go.
 

SunkissedBri

General Manager
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
Reactions
27,211 772 1,013
33,882
Alleybux
525
I absolutely agree. I was speaking on the false information her goofy ass posted and apparently the girls don't like when facts are posted that challenge their bµllsh!t ass narratives

You ain't post not a single damn fact. All you posted was tears & insults. The minute you go for insults, you lose! To the ignore list you go!

7WAm.gif
 

TheReal_Ness

Team Owner
Joined
May 14, 2007
Messages
10,487
Reaction score
Reactions
39,535 727 457
43,537
Alleybux
518,602
Stfy lyinggg! You can't prove sh!t that you posted. I actually posted #s but if you weren't an overly emotional, butt hurt illiterate bird, you would've seen it :laughing:

Lil girl, this my last time even entertaining your goofy ass because I can't help but laugh now. You said "she wasn't a catalyst for the soundtrack"-- I stated she was exec producer and there is actual video footage corroborating that because she spoke on the artists she wanted on the soundtrack. You posted Romeo Must Die wasn't a hit film-- another lie because it actually was a hit film, the critics loved her in it as well, Joel Silver actually was going to work with her again due to it. The only factual thing your inept ass posted was first week sales and a chart position. Everything else you said was purely your own opinion/narrative. If you don't know what those words mean, get a fµck!ng dictionary.
 

BLVCK

always disgusted
Joined
Dec 25, 2013
Messages
8,593
Reaction score
Reactions
157,233 5,834 3,948
185,751
Alleybux
35,588
You ain't post not a single damn fact. All you posted was tears & insults. The minute you go for insults, you lose! To the ignore list you go!

7WAm.gif
Lil girl, this my last time even entertaining your goofy ass because I can't help but laugh now. You said "she wasn't a catalyst for the soundtrack"-- I stated she was exec producer and there is actual video footage corroborating that because she spoke on the artists she wanted on the soundtrack. You posted Romeo Must Die wasn't a hit film-- another lie because it actually was a hit film, the critics loved her in it as well, Joel Silver actually was going to work with her again due to it. The only factual thing your inept ass posted was first week sales and a chart position. Everything else you said was purely your own opinion/narrative. If you don't know what those words mean, get a fµck!ng dictionary.
Now y’all done both pissed me off. Leave!! Boffaya!!!


tenor.gif
 

TheReal_Ness

Team Owner
Joined
May 14, 2007
Messages
10,487
Reaction score
Reactions
39,535 727 457
43,537
Alleybux
518,602
Now y’all done both pissed me off. Leave!! Boffaya!!!


tenor.gif


Children need to be supervised while using the internet. These 90's/2000's born kids need something else to do in this pandemic Chile. But the bird is ignored. Take it up with God and the internet provider.
 

SunkissedBri

General Manager
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
Reactions
27,211 772 1,013
33,882
Alleybux
525
WAIT A MINUTEEEEEEEEE

eve.png


Stop talking to one another! You both said what you said now let it go.

I'm gucci. Ms swamp pussy came at me first, popping sh!t bc she can't control her fµck!ng emotions, calling me out my mfing name, so I had to let that b!tch know! Anyways, it's a lovely day outside :):heart_eyes:
 
Last edited:

bbal246

General Manager
Joined
Feb 10, 2017
Messages
4,597
Reaction score
Reactions
47,587 1,701 194
52,512
Alleybux
363,672
How does a thread on which song someone prefers devolve into who had a better career? All three ladies had good careers and are among the best selling female acts in R&B. All three were influential let's leave it at that and stick to the question at hand.
 

candybling

Starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2015
Messages
199
Reaction score
Reactions
3,043 79 62
4,023
Alleybux
8,600
"brokenhearted" & "why i love you so much" are almost a tie for me, but i'm gonna give the edge to monica. i played "brokenhearted" more in the 90s but these days i connect more with "why i love you so much."

"the one i gave my heart to" was a good song but it didn't suit aaliyah's vocals or overall vibe at all. brandy would've killed that song tho
 

CarmenJonesGal

Team Owner
Joined
Feb 27, 2014
Messages
52,708
Solutions
1
Reaction score
Reactions
367,532 10,220 2,157
438,256
Alleybux
165,347
Monica- that song captured the feelings of first love so perfectly.
I remember the first time hearing that track, someone was playing it on the train and my young az just had my first heartbreak and I was swallowing lumps that entire train ride
tenor.gif

Lol
 

Akimbo

Cheverly Remembrance Week: April 15-21
Joined
Jan 26, 2014
Messages
39,964
Solutions
5
Reaction score
Reactions
332,581 20,842 4,107
391,844
Alleybux
988,260
I loved all three of the these songs, but had to go with Brokenhearted. It just does something to my heart.

Aaliyah's death really reduced the impact of her music. In the 90s, Brandy and Monica stood no chance against Aaliyah. So many people loved her music and respected her craft.
Y’all have got to stop lying on Aaliyah. While she was definitely one of the girls, she was not theee girl and that’s okay. You guys only bring negative comments upon yourselves and Aaliyah when you do this.
 

blkmyrrhmade

General Manager
Joined
Oct 4, 2008
Messages
3,933
Reaction score
Reactions
28,882 641 33
29,751
Alleybux
158,768
I voted for "Why I Love You So Much".
But the original version of "Brokenhearted" w/o Wanye hits different!
 
Joined
May 22, 2019
Messages
16,831
Reaction score
Reactions
146,849 4,503 3,835
182,052
Alleybux
933,602
I love Aaliyah, but it’s unfair to put any of her ballads up against Brandy or Monica’s. Aaliyah was not a ballad singer. She was known for her uptempo hits which had a sound that was unprecedented and still stands the test of time today. And even though she was in the same age group as Brandy and Monica, in many ways it sort of felt like she wasn’t. She was in a lane all her own.

With that said, I love both “Brokenhearted” and “Why I Love You So Much.” It’s really a tie between the two songs. However, if I had to choose, I’d choose “Why I Love You So Much” because it still gets heavy rotation from me all these years later.
 

Chile

Team Owner
Joined
Jun 10, 2020
Messages
8,404
Reaction score
Reactions
61,920 1,977 692
68,255
Alleybux
624,062




Interestingly, all three songs peaked at #9 on Billboard Hot 100.

Broken-hearted reminds me of my sophomore year of high school. Right around the age I had my lil feelings hurt by a guy for the 1st time LOL.
I used to be in my room with that song in repeat !!
 

MeEverday

General Manager
Joined
Nov 30, 2015
Messages
4,749
Reaction score
Reactions
39,200 1,581 1,143
42,743
Alleybux
546,371
All of them are great, but I listen to "Why I Love You So Much" at least three times a week.
 

THA RAQ

It's Ugly Here!
Joined
Dec 1, 2017
Messages
15,177
Reaction score
Reactions
189,107 4,340 1,314
227,323
Alleybux
14,218
Excuse me?! The audacity! You clearly didn't experience the 90s bc aaliyah ain't have sh!t on monica & damn sure not on brandy. Brandy was the fµck!ng sh!t in the 90s. She was the top teen r&b artist. Brandy had her own doll, multi platinum albums & her own tv show when was 15. Aaliyah wasn't selling records like brandy. Aaliyah did not have that & she doesn't sing better than brandy & monica. Y'all stay trying to canonize aaliyah. Everybody else act like they're scared to say it but imma say it. Aaliyah was not popping like that in the 90s. Period
I'll probably get scalped for this but when it comes to Aaliyah the historical revisionism is real.

Brandy RULED the 90's and Monica was always second. Though Aaliyah did have a following and great music she wasn't a huge star. Her death made her a legend.
 

Ms Her

Ms Her
Joined
Sep 5, 2007
Messages
9,988
Reaction score
Reactions
26,243 702 145
27,830
Alleybux
4,500
I can't pick one as the best. They all hit deep at different points, in the same relationship, with the same dude, thankfully back then and nevermore! ( sorry, my nerd channeled poetic prose and a Raven reference).
 

Kano1987

LSA OG Fav! 2009 til infinity
Joined
Nov 14, 2009
Messages
56,666
Reaction score
Reactions
328,301 12,228 7,479
366,945
Alleybux
395,597
Brokenhearted!


Brandy and Monica = Incredible


Aaliyah is no for me, RIP. I was born in 1987 and experienced the 90's; she wasn't on Brandy/Monica level back then.
 

SunkissedBri

General Manager
Joined
Jun 27, 2019
Messages
3,845
Reaction score
Reactions
27,211 772 1,013
33,882
Alleybux
525
I'll probably get scalped for this but when it comes to Aaliyah the historical revisionism is real.

Brandy RULED the 90's and Monica was always second. Though Aaliyah did have a following and great music she wasn't a huge star. Her death made her a legend.

And it's ridiculous bc you shouldn't have to feel that way. People just can't handle the truth. I keep trying to tell mfs she wasn't that popular but they always wanna throw tantrums & sh!t :rolleyes: it's ridiculous how she keeps getting compared to or put above artists like beyonce, brandy etc when she wasn't as popular, talented nor did numbers like them. All they gotta do is check the soundscan from the 90s but they don't wanna do that bc the truth hurts. One time somebody got mad bc I compared aaliyah to jhene aiko :laughing:
 

Currv

Team Owner
Joined
May 3, 2020
Messages
8,135
Reaction score
Reactions
42,044 1,598 529
44,880
Alleybux
489,000




Interestingly, all three songs peaked at #9 on Billboard Hot 100.

Looking back, these three were light years ahead of their time. Especially compared to these artists of today. Looking back you can really appreciate the artistry, talent, and the music they all brought to the table. And they all were out simultaneously and all successful.
 

THA RAQ

It's Ugly Here!
Joined
Dec 1, 2017
Messages
15,177
Reaction score
Reactions
189,107 4,340 1,314
227,323
Alleybux
14,218
And it's ridiculous bc you shouldn't have to feel that way. People just can't handle the truth. I keep trying to tell mfs she wasn't that popular but they always wanna throw tantrums & sh!t :rolleyes: it's ridiculous how she keeps getting compared to or put above artists like beyonce, brandy etc when she wasn't as popular, talented nor did numbers like them. All they gotta do is check the soundscan from the 90s but they don't wanna do that bc the truth hurts. One time somebody got mad bc I compared aaliyah to jhene aiko :laughing:
I'm convinced that a lot of those people who dispute these facts weren't born yet.
 

Similar Threads

Trending Threads

News Alley

Ask LSA

The Lounge

General Alley

Top Bottom