greenluxi
Team Owner
what vocals were stolen? Ashanti's demo vocals were kept on I'm Real and Ashanti wrote Ain't It Funny for Jennifer.........if stealing was involved, I don't think Ashanti would've continued to work with her.
Sia's vocals were kept on Beyonce's Pretty Hurts, God Made You Beautiful and Standing on the Sun.....no one talks about that......
Okay, I'll try another way. You post the top 5 performances, live vocal performances of both Jlo and Beyonce, and we'll discuss talent. Like I said, and I was very fair, both of these entertainers struggle in the originality department, but if you peel back set design and customs and music videos, and you put them both on a stage and give them five songs each to prove their vocal talent Jlo is not coming out the victor in that. It's as simple as it gets.
Also, it's about the amount of the original vocals left on the track as well, meaning keeping backing vocals for harmonic layering in the hook only is a lot different than keeping the majority of the demo vocals on the entirety of the track, and the lead vocalist essentially doing the back up vocal. Do you think Jlo is a more talented vocalist than Beyonce, prime vs prime?
Edit: I'll also add, that there is a major difference in your huge career-defining singles being mostly someone else's vocals, vs. smaller less recognizable tracks being fused with demo vocals. Also, all of that gets further voided if you can not properly sing those songs live and couldn't properly rerecord them if necessary.